The utility and validity for public health of ethnicity categorisation in the 1991, 2001 and 2011 British censuses

Objectives

To evaluate the utility and validity of the ethnicity categorizations across the 1991, 2001 and 2011 British Censuses for public health purposes.

Study design

Narrative review.

Methods

A review of journal literature and census and other policy reports was undertaken to assess specified criteria for the utility and validity of the 1991, 2001 and 2011 Censuses for public health.

Results

The census ethnicity categorization satisfactorily captures the ethnic diversity of the population, and adheres to the principle of self-identification in the labels used and underlying conceptual base. The stability of some of the categories (especially ‘Black’ groups and ‘Mixed’) continues to be problematic for public health. Concealed heterogeneity has been partially addressed in the ‘White’ group but remains in the ‘Black African’ group. Colour categories (‘White’ and ‘Black’) have been retained in the 2011 Census, with only limited objection amongst the communities they describe.

Conclusions

The complexity of the classifications and range of data on the dimensions of ethnicity have increased over the three decades. The breakdown of the ‘Black African’ group, the shortcomings of ‘Mixed’ categorization, and the way in which the ‘White’ category is subdivided require further investigation.