Skip to main content

Names, Nonsubstitutivity and the Tanney Puzzle

Goldstein, Laurence (2011) Names, Nonsubstitutivity and the Tanney Puzzle. In: Munz, Volker and Puhl, Klaus and Wang, Joseph, eds. Language and World. Part Two: Signs, Minds and Actions. Ontos Verlag, 15 . Kirchberg am Wechsel : Austrian Ludwig Wittgenstein Society, Frankfurt, pp. 23-37. ISBN 978-3-86838-080-4. (KAR id:28023)

Microsoft Word
Language: English
Download (91kB)
[thumbnail of Nonsubstitutivity_and_the_Tanney_Puzzle.doc]
This file may not be suitable for users of assistive technology.
Request an accessible format


Most people would accept as true

1) Lois kissed Superman before she kissed Clark Kent.

but would reject as false

2) Lois kissed Superman before she kissed Superman.

We should note that even a linguistically competent individual who is well acquainted with the movie and who is fully aware that Superman just is Clark Kent would be willing to accept 1) as an accurate description of part of the action. Julia Tanney accepts this too, but is then struck by an apparent anomaly. She writes:

Normally, I would be very sympathetic with the claim that there was a time, t1, at which Lois kissed Superman but not (yet) Clark Kent. I note however that the sense in which Lois (at t1) had not (yet) kissed Clark Kent would be the same as that in which Oedipus, although having slept with Jocasta, had not slept with his mother. But Jocasta hanged herself and Oedipus gouged out his eyes because there was no question for them of not accepting substitutivity.

Apart from the change of dramatis personae, the apparently only noteworthy difference between the kissing claim 1) and

3) Oedipus slept with Jocasta before he slept with his mother.

is that less clothes and more action are involved, yet somehow, intuitively, we take 1) to be true and 3) false. So this is the Tanney puzzle, and the challenge is to find a plausible rationale for this difference in truth-value assignment. That is what I attempt in this article

Item Type: Book section
Subjects: B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion
Divisions: Divisions > Division of Arts and Humanities > School of Culture and Languages
Depositing User: Laurence Goldstein
Date Deposited: 22 Jul 2011 11:02 UTC
Last Modified: 16 Nov 2021 10:06 UTC
Resource URI: (The current URI for this page, for reference purposes)
  • Depositors only (login required):


Downloads per month over past year