Skip to main content
Kent Academic Repository

Contentment is not consent: capacity, the subjective element of Article 5, and the unequal liberty of disabled people

Wells, Craig (2026) Contentment is not consent: capacity, the subjective element of Article 5, and the unequal liberty of disabled people. Medical Law Review, 34 (4). ISSN 0967-0742. (doi:10.1093/medlaw/fwag042) (KAR id:117727)

Abstract

In A Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland [2026] UKSC 16, the Supreme Court invoked the 1966 Practice Statement to overrule Cheshire West, holding that an adult who lacks the mental capacity to decide upon their care arrangements may nonetheless give valid consent to confinement, for the purposes of the subjective element of Storck v Germany, by manifesting contentment with those arrangements. This article argues that the decision is wrong twice over. Conceptually, it commits a category error: across the law, consent is a communicated legal power conditioned upon capacity, and contentment is a mental state which exercises nothing. Normatively, it produces unequal protection: the conditions upon which a capacitous person may be taken outside Article 5 are policed with rigour, while a disabled person may now be removed from its protection upon an inference about their mood, drawn by those who confine them. The article reads the Strasbourg tacit-acceptance cases as capacity-sensitive, examines the court’s selective re-evaluation of MIG, MEG, and P, and answers the defences of workability and residual protection. The cure for Cheshire West’s burdens was a better scheme of safeguards, not the evisceration of consent.

Item Type: Article
DOI/Identification number: 10.1093/medlaw/fwag042
Subjects: K Law
Institutional Unit: Schools > Kent Law School
Former Institutional Unit:
There are no former institutional units.
Funders: University of Kent (https://ror.org/00xkeyj56)
Depositing User: Craig Wells
Date Deposited: 12 Nov 2026 12:33 UTC
Last Modified: 12 Nov 2026 16:07 UTC
Resource URI: https://kar.kent.ac.uk/id/eprint/117727 (The current URI for this page, for reference purposes)

University of Kent Author Information

Wells, Craig.

Creator's ORCID:
CReDIT Contributor Roles:
  • Depositors only (login required):

Total unique views of this page since July 2020. For more details click on the image.